How to Choose a Shingle: Expert Guide for Homeowners

How to Choose a Shingle — homeowner comparing asphalt shingle samples, cutaway of shingle layers, and a finished roof at sunset for a new home.

Your home deserves a roof that looks great, lasts longer, and protects year-round.

Table of Contents

  1. Why your shingle choice matters

  2. Types of asphalt shingles: 3-tab vs architectural

  3. Key performance metrics to compare

  4. Style, color, and neighborhood harmony

  5. Warranty, cost, and ROI

  6. Tips for hiring a shingle contractor

  7. Final call & contact

1. Why Your Shingle Choice Matters

Your roof is more than just a cover—it’s your home’s first line of defense. The right shingle protects you from storms, controls energy costs, and boosts resale value. As a Dayton Ohio roofing authority with 65+ years in this business, Thrush & Son® believes every homeowner deserves clear guidance.

2. Types of Asphalt Shingles: 3-Tab vs Architectural

The most common choice homeowners face is between 3-tab shingles and architectural (dimensional) shingles. Here’s how they stack up:

  • 3-Tab Shingles

    • Pros: Lower cost, lighter weight, easier installation.

    • Cons: Flatter look, shorter lifespan, lower wind/photo resistance.

    • Typical warranty: 20–25 years.

    • Limitations: In strong wind zones, they often max out around 60–70 mph wind ratings. Today’s Homeowner+2O’Donnell Roofing Co.+2

  • Architectural (Dimensional) Shingles

In many modern and upscale neighborhoods, architectural shingles have become the standard. The 3-tab style is still viable, especially for budget-conscious or secondary buildings, but its limitations are more exposed on homes that expect longevity.

3. Key Performance Metrics to Compare

Here’s what to weigh when comparing shingles:

Metric Why It Matters Ideal Benchmark
Wind Rating Indicates how well the shingle resists uplift in storms ≥ 110–130 mph for Dayton’s weather zone
Algae / Stain Resistance Reduces discoloration in shaded areas Good manufacturers include special granules or treatments
Warranty Type Stronger warranties often reflect better material & installation 30+ years or lifetime, non-prorated where possible
Weight & Thickness Heavier shingles resist warping, curling 300+ lb per square for premium architectural
Granule Adhesion Less granule loss = longer life Look for warranties on granule loss

A cheap shingle with poor wind ratings or granule shedding will cost more down the stretch in repairs and replacements.

4. Style, Color & Neighborhood Harmony

The “right” shingle isn’t just about durability—appearance is huge. Some tips:

  • Match your home style. A Colonial, Cape, or Craftsman home often looks better with architectural shingles that have depth and shadow lines.

  • Choose colors with contrast. Trim, siding, and fascia should complement—not blend.

  • Consider neighboring homes. In many newer neighborhoods, there’s an unstated standard for roofing aesthetics. Going too out-of-line can reduce resale appeal.

  • Use the manufacturer’s visualizer tools. Many brands (GAF, CertainTeed, Owens Corning) let you “see” shingle colors on your own home before you pick.

5. Warranty, Cost & Return on Investment

You’ll pay more for premium materials and installation, but the long-term payoff can be massive.

  • Costs: Architectural shingles often cost 20–50% more upfront than 3-tab equivalents. Franciscus Roofing+2New England Metal Roof+2

  • Lifespan & value: Architectural shingles frequently last 30–50 years; 3-tab more often 15–25 years in the Dayton region. Home Genius Exteriors+2Wikipedia+2

  • Resale impact: Buyers notice a rich, dimensional roof. A well-installed architectural roof can add tens of thousands to perceived home value.

  • Warranties matter: Make sure your contractor’s workmanship and the manufacturer’s warranty are both solid. A strong warranty is useless if your install voids it.

6. Tips for Hiring a Shingle Contractor

  • Get certified installers. Look for GAF, CertainTeed, or Owens Corning certifications.

  • Check references. Ask to see recent full installations, not just shingle patches.

  • Request a roof audit. Your contractor should inspect flashing, decking, ventilation, and warranty conditions before quoting.

  • Clarify roof tear-off. Some jobs require removing old layers—others don’t.

  • Get everything in writing. Warranties, materials, project timeline, cleanup—all spelled out.

Schedule & Service

Thinking it’s time for a roof upgrade?
📞 Call 937.833.5136 or hit Schedule below.
Local, certified inspectors — Dayton’s trusted roofing crew since 1960.

Thrush & Son® has been elevating homes across the region for over six decades. From Kettering and Beavercreek to Miamisburg, Mason, Lebanon, and Northern Kentucky, we’re your full-service exterior partner: roofing, siding, windows, and doors. Ready to start? Let’s walk through your vision—no pressure, all clarity.

Want More Expert Insights?

Don’t miss our post on Architectural Shingles: Elevating Curb Appeal & Protection — discover how premium shingles pay returns in aesthetics and durability. Read it here:
https://www.thrushandson.com/blog/architectural-shingles-offer-aesthetic-appeal-and-protection-courtesy-of-gaf-i-thrush-son-i-your-hometown-contractor/

🔗 Stay Connected