Which Home Improvements Offer the Best ROI?

Table of Contents

Why ROI Matters in Home Improvement

Home improvement ROI matters more than ever. With rising material costs and shifting home values, every project should give something back. Whether you’re upgrading your roof, replacing siding, installing new windows, or refreshing your entryway, it pays to understand which improvements deliver the biggest return. In this guide, we break down the top 5 projects that maximize both value and curb appeal — all backed by real data and local insight from Thrush & Son®.

Understanding home improvement ROI isn’t just about what you spend—it’s about what you get back. Whether you’re in Dayton, Centerville, Mason, Troy, Florence, or Burlington, these projects are worth every penny.

1. Shingle vs. Metal Roofing ROI

Comparison of shingle roofing versus metal roofing with return on investment percentages.

Shingle roofing averages a 60–65% ROI, while metal roofing delivers 85–90%—helping homeowners make smart investment decisions.

Shingle roofing in Dayton, Ohio remains the go-to for affordability and strong return, averaging 60–65% ROI. For those looking long-term, metal roofing in places like Florence or Mason can return 85–90% thanks to its durability and reflective energy-saving properties.

According to Remodeling Magazine’s latest report, both options boost curb appeal and resale confidence dramatically.

2. New Replacement Windows ROI

Energy-efficient white-framed double-hung replacement window with text highlighting 68–74% ROI and reduced energy costs.

New replacement windows offer 68–74% ROI and help homeowners reduce energy bills—making them a smart upgrade in Ohio and Northern Kentucky.

Modern replacement windows typically return 68–74% ROI and immediately reduce your heating and cooling bills.

The ENERGY STAR program confirms that certified vinyl windows can save homeowners hundreds annually in energy costs—especially valuable during our Ohio winters and Northern Kentucky summers.

3. Vinyl Siding & Curb Appeal ROI

Beige vinyl siding with white-trimmed window and flower bed, showing 76–82% ROI for improved curb appeal.

Vinyl siding offers 76–82% ROI and boosts your home’s curb appeal and value in Ohio and Northern Kentucky.

New vinyl siding installation can return 76–82% ROI, and with smart color choices and accents (like shakes or stone veneer), the curb appeal impact is instant.

4. Entry Door Replacement ROI

Front entry door with white trim and navy finish showing 100% ROI for home value and curb appeal.

Replacing your front entry door delivers up to 100% ROI and instantly boosts your home’s curb appeal and security.

Replacing your entry door with a modern steel or fiberglass model brings up to 100% ROI, while adding security, energy efficiency, and a beautiful first impression.

Bonus: What About a Kitchen Remodel?

Now please create me all the alt text, title, caption and description relating to this photo and this blog.

A minor kitchen remodel offers a 72–78% ROI and adds lasting value to your home.

According to the National Association of Realtors, a minor kitchen remodel can return 72–78% ROI, especially with classic designs and functional layouts.

Downloadable Checklist

Download our Free ROI Checklist

  • Roofing (shingle vs. metal) ROI stats
  • Energy savings from new windows
  • Curb appeal scoring for siding
  • Entry door security & style factors
  • Bonus kitchen remodel tracker

Bottom-Funnel Insight: ROI, Energy & Long-Term Savings

Let’s break it down:

  • ✅ ROI = Value + Savings + Comfort
  • ✅ These upgrades increase resale appeal and reduce monthly costs
  • ✅ Over time, they pay for themselves

Request a free estimate from Thrush & Son or explore more home improvement insights on our blog.

Thrush & Son® is proud to serve communities throughout the Miami Valley and Northern Kentucky—including Dayton, Centerville, Springboro, Mason, Maineville, Troy, Vandalia, Florence, Dry Ridge, and Union. We’re not just roofing experts; we specialize in full exterior remodeling, including siding, windows, and doors. If you’re considering a home improvement project and want to make a smart investment, we’re here to guide you every step of the way.